Linear Actuators vs Rotary Motors in Ventilation Systems

Linear Actuators vs Rotary Motors in Ventilation Systems

Nathan Bong
Nathan Bong
PA Engineer

In an ever-changing world of HVAC (Heating, Ventilation, and Air Conditioning) systems, innovations continue to emerge, improving efficiency, control, and energy use. Two such pivotal components in automated ventilation systems are linear actuators and rotary motors. Each plays a crucial role in controlling airflow and optimizing the climate within buildings. In this article, we will highlight critical details of linear actuators and rotary motors, exploring their workings, advantages, and applications in automated ventilation systems.

 

Overview of Linear Actuators

Electric linear actuator

 

Actuators take an input energy source, typically electrical, hydraulic, or pneumatic, and convert it into a physical movement. Linear actuators are devices that create motion in a straight line, as opposed to the rotary motion of a traditional motor. Electric linear actuators are the most common source of linear motion for ventilation systems due to their precision and ease of integration with modern control systems. In electric linear actuators, electric current is used to produce rotational motion in an electric motor that’s mechanically linked to a gearbox and utilizes a lead screw to cycle the actuator’s shaft attached to an ACME drill nut for linear motion.

 

Explore our collection of electric linear actuators, from micro to industrial capabilities!

Overview of Rotary Motors

A brushed DC motor

 

In contrast, rotary motors are designed to produce rotary motion and operate on the principle of electromagnetism. When an electric current passes through a coil within the motor, it generates a magnetic field that interacts with another magnetic field, causing the motor's shaft to rotate. A brushed DC motor is perhaps one of the simpler types of rotary motors, however, they also come in AC variants with multiple phases. This rotary motion from the shaft is then transferred to other components directly or indirectly through a series of gears in a gearbox linked to the shaft.

 

Pros and Cons in Ventilation Systems: Linear Actuators vs Rotary Motors

Within the context of automated ventilation systems, the pros and cons of linear actuators and rotary motors vary due to their unique design and characteristics.

Precision Control

Linear actuator technology offers superior precision and control over airflow due to its ability to make fine adjustments in the position of vents and dampers. This precision translates into better management of indoor air quality and comfort levels, as the system can respond swiftly to changes in environmental conditions or user preferences.

Consistent Airflow

Rotary motors may not independently offer the same level of control over the direction or volume of air; however, they excel in generating consistent airflow. They are essential for the overall movement of air and would then be coupled with other mechanisms, like dampers controlled by linear actuators, to achieve precise airflow control.

Energy Efficiency

In terms of energy efficiency in ventilation, linear actuators can be more energy-efficient because they only consume power when moving to adjust the position of a vent or damper. Once in place, the lead screw design requires no additional energy to maintain its position, which promotes energy savings in the long run. Rotary motors are often in continuous operation which can lead to higher energy consumption, especially in systems that run non-stop.

Get a complete A-Z guide on how to select, test, and implement linear motion for any application! 

Applications in Ventilation Systems

Ventilation system

 

Electric linear actuators find their primary applications in the fine-tuning of air distribution systems. They are instrumental in applications where linear motion is needed, such as in the movement of dampers and vents in automated ventilation systems. The primary function of electric linear actuators in automated ventilation systems is to adjust the position of these components, allowing for precise airflow control. They're often used in variable air volume (VAV) systems, where precise airflow control is necessary to maintain desired climate conditions across different zones within a building.

Automated ventilation system

 

Rotary motors are indispensable in many applications, including driving pumps and fan blades, which are integral for moving air through automated ventilation systems and into spaces. In ventilation, rotary motors are primarily responsible for creating and maintaining airflow, ensuring that air circulates efficiently throughout a space. They are fundamental to the basic operation of automated ventilation systems, providing the essential circulation needed to maintain indoor air quality.

 

Where Linear Actuators and Rotary Motors Work Best

Automated ventilation system

 

Choosing between linear actuators and rotary motors in ventilation systems is less about selecting one over the other and depends more on understanding how they complement each other in the unique roles they play. Electric linear actuators provide the precision and control needed for optimal air distribution, while rotary motors ensure that air is consistently moved through the system.

When designing or selecting an automated ventilation system, it's essential to consider how these electromechanical components can be integrated to achieve the desired balance of airflow control, energy efficiency, and maintenance requirements. By leveraging the strengths of both linear actuators and rotary motors, HVAC professionals can create systems that deliver both comfort and efficiency for users.

View the different use cases and industries that have benefited from our linear actuators!

IN SUMMARY  

Electric linear actuators and rotary motors play their own unique and important roles in forming the backbone of efficient, automated ventilation systems. Understanding these components can provide valuable insights into the workings of the systems that keep our indoor environments comfortable and healthy.

As one of the top suppliers of electric linear actuators and motion control products, Progressive Automations offers industry-leading flexibility, quality, support, and field experience to meet all your needs. If you have any other questions about what we can offer, please do not hesitate to reach out to us! We are experts in what we do and want to ensure you find the best solutions for linear actuators in HVAC systems.

sales@progressiveautomations.com | 1-800-676-6123

 

Nathan Bong

Engineer & Copywriting Specialist at Progressive Automations, Progressive Desk, and Progressive Bed
Nathan Bong, Engineer & Copywriting Specialist at Progressive Automations, Progressive Desk, and Progressive Bed, handles the creation and revision of technical content such as articles, datasheets, user manuals, technical videos, and case studies. As a graduate of BCIT, he has an academic background in electrical and computer engineering while also having hands-on experience of working with electrical equipment and tools.